The two kinds of standard clauses
The GDPR provides standard clauses for two things.
Those under Article 46 are for transferring data outside the European Economic Area. Those under Article 28 are for drafting the contract between controller and processor, even with no transfer. When a supplier mentions standard clauses, it is worth asking which ones.
Why it matters
They appear in almost every processing agreement from software suppliers with sub-processors outside the EU.
Sometimes as the basis of the transfer and sometimes as a fallback, in case an adequacy decision falls. Reading a contract means knowing whether it includes them and what for.
What the GDPR requires
Article 46 of the GDPR lists the Commission standard clauses among the appropriate safeguards, with three features.
- They need no express authorisation from the supervisory authority (paragraph 2).
- They only work if individuals have enforceable rights and effective legal remedies (paragraph 1).
- They are signed between whoever sends the data from the EU and whoever receives it outside.
Not enough on their own
The Spanish data protection authority (AEPD) points out that, with the 2021 clauses, the exporter still has to assess the law of the destination country.
Signing them does not settle what can be done with the data there.
The 2021 clauses
The current clauses replace the three sets adopted under the directive that preceded the GDPR.
A contract that still cites the old ones is out of date, and it is worth asking for the new version.
What to ask a supplier
Three checks are enough to read this part of a processing agreement.
- Whether it includes the clauses of Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 and for which transfers.
- Whether they always apply or only as a fallback, when another safeguard fails.
- Which sub-processors receive the data outside the European Economic Area.