Transfer and the supplier’s nationality
A US supplier does not automatically mean a transfer, and a supplier that says “data in the EU” does not automatically mean there is none.
What counts is whether the data reaches a recipient outside the European Economic Area, for example one of its sub-processors or its parent company.
Why it matters
A customer service tool holds the conversations of every customer, and many suppliers have their parent company or some sub-processors in the United States.
Whether there is a transfer, and on what safeguard, is one of the first things legal asks. The company also records it in its record of processing activities.
When it is allowed
The GDPR allows an international transfer through two main routes.
- Adequacy decision. The Commission declares that the country protects data to an adequate level, and the transfer needs no specific authorisation (Article 45).
- Appropriate safeguards. Commission standard clauses, approved binding corporate rules, codes of conduct or certifications, always with enforceable rights for individuals (Article 46).
The United States
The United States has had an adequacy decision since 10 July 2023, the EU-US Data Privacy Framework.
It only covers companies that have joined the framework. The Commission published its first review on 9 October 2024. With a company outside the framework, standard clauses or another Article 46 safeguard are needed.
What to ask a supplier
Before contracting a support tool it is worth having four answers in writing.
- Whether any data leaves the European Economic Area, including backups and AI models.
- Which sub-processors are outside it and what for.
- On what safeguard, and in which clause of the contract it appears.
- Whether it gives notice before starting a new transfer.