Short answer
It depends on how many people answer and how much you use the AI. Intercom charges per user plus per resolution by its AI agent; Zendesk charges per user plus its AI add-on. With a small team and a lot of automated volume, Intercom usually costs more; with a large team and little AI, it’s the other way around.
In detail
Why the comparisons contradict each other
Because you pay for two different things. A team of three with two thousand conversations a month pays little for users and a lot for resolutions; a team of fifteen with five hundred conversations pays the opposite. Any figure that ignores those two numbers is a guess.
How to do the math
Two multiplications, users times price per user, plus automated conversations per month times price per resolution. Use last month’s volume, not the volume you hope for, and repeat it with your busiest month of the year.
What tips the balance
If your volume grows with customers and your team doesn’t, per-resolution pricing works out better over time even if it looks worse today. If your volume is steady and your team grows, the opposite. Look at which price grows with the thing you plan to grow.